Wednesday, May 6, 2009

A New Economy with Nearly-Universal Healthcare?

Whenever the U.S. economy fully recovers (including on the job front), our nation will likely witness some significant changes in how health care is managed in this country.  Both Democrats and Republicans realize that healthcare in this country needs to be reformed...but in terms of what reforms will need to be made, the two parties will have to duke it out.  Democrats are clearly going after a nearly-universal healthcare system by proposing a government-run healthcare program to compete with hundreds of privately-run programs.  The Republican party is warming up to the idea of universal health care, but only if it is completely administered through the private sector.  But to do so, Republicans will have to work to get a seat at the negotation table.  How?  By re-framing the debate.

The Republican Framing of the Healthcare Debate  via Ben Smith:



THE QUESTION YOU MUST ASK EVERY HEALTH CARE TOWN HALL FORUM
Would you rather… 
“Pay the costs you pay today for the quality of care you currently receive,”
-- OR-- 
“Pay less for your care, but potentially have to wait weeks for tests and months for treatments you need.”
Their Answer:
OVERWHELMINGLY KEEP THE CURRENT ARRANGEMENT

The Democrats already have an answer for this: They're bending over backward to make sure the majority who are comfortable with their care won't be affected. So the burden is on the GOP to prove otherwise.


Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Green Shoots

The buzz the past couple of weeks is that the economy is bottoming and that we are beginning to witness "green shoots."  The stock market is experiencing a sustained bear market rally, which historically has been a nine month (give or take a month) leading indicator of broad economic recovery.  But what is the basis for the equities market's "leading economic indicator" status?  

Since the Great Depression, most economic recessions have lasted equal to or less than 12 months. Here we are now, though, in our 17th month of this Great Recession.   Given the inability of the market to value toxic assets, the lack of transparency of the investment banks, and the still frozen credit markets...does "leading economic indicator status" during these strange times even apply here?  Without knowing the economic mechanism behind the historical correlation, it is pretty much useless in giving us any real reason for confidence.   

But don't worry about the great 1-2 year lagging economic indicator: job recovery.  We can count on that!

Thursday, April 30, 2009

What Does the Market Think of BofA and Citi?

First, some data on BofA and Citibank:

Bank of America
Net Equity (as of end of March 2009) = $ 240 Billion
Market Capitalization (as of Apr 30, 2009) = $57.16 Billion

Citibank
Net Equity (as of end of March 2009) = $ 144 Billion
Market Capitalization (as of Apr 30, 2009) = $16.81 Billion

One explanation for these numbers, besides a cash flow problem,  is that the market believes that some of their underlying assets are incorrectly valued. 

Stressing over Stress Tests

What is the current state of the finance industry in this country?   The results of the bank "stress tests" for the top 19 banks (by asset value) are seen by many independent analysts to be unconvincing.  Last week, the Federal Reserve stated that the vast majority were sufficiently capitalized to withstand an even greater economic downturn than the one we are currently experiencing.  Yet, this week, Bank of America and Citibank (with almost $4 Trillion in assets, combined) were told to each raise over $70 Billion in capital.  High unemployment rates are not going away anytime soon and an economic recovery is not likely to be seen until the beginning of next year even under the rosiest of circumstances.  What will happen to BofA and Citi in the meantime?

John Browne, Sr. Strategist at EuroPacific Capital had this to say:

"First, the level of stress in the tests was set unrealistically low. Their absolute worst case assumption was for a GDP contraction of only 3.3 percent in 2009. This comes as first quarter 2009 GDP shrank at 6.1 percent. And the economy is still slowing. To post a contraction of just 3.3 percent for the year would likely involve an immediate reversal in the rate of contraction and outright expansion by the fourth quarter.

The stress test also assumes a worst case scenario unemployment rate of 8.9 percent in 2009. This is also wildly optimistic when unemployment is already at 8.7 percent and rising at some 20,000 each day. Worse still, if calculated on a pre-Clinton basis, to include all those unable to find anything but part-time employment, the current unemployment rate is a staggering 19.2 percent, or just 0.8 percent from official depression levels! It appears that the U.S. is fast slipping from recession into depression, rendering the stress tests almost meaningless other than as a public morale boosting exercise." 

More on this here.

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

DHOTUS (Debt Holders Of The United States)

Who are the top-ten holders of U.S. debt (in the form of U.S. Treasuries)?

1.  Federal Reserve and IntraGovernmental Holdings ($4.8 Trillion)
2.  Mutual Funds/ Money Market (769 Billion)
3.  China (740 Billion)
4.  Japan (635 Billion)
5.  State and Local Governments (523 Billion)
6.  Pension Funds (456 Billion)
7.  Other (individuals, trusts, brokers, etc)  (413 Billion)
8.  Oil Exporting Countries (Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Venezuela, etc.) (186 Billion)
9.  Off-shore Caribbean Banks (177 Billion)
10.  Brazil (134 Billion)
Foreign Governments in italics.
Numbers from CNBC.

The Top Ten hold $8.8 Trillion of an estimated $11.1 Trillion in total U.S. debt.  Notice that China and Japan combined only hold slightly more than 10% of U.S. Treasuries.  So...China has to worry about fluctuations in the U.S. dollar...and tries to exert influence to maintain its investment...but there are plenty of other countries and institutions begging to lend the U.S. money in their flight to an investment safe haven!


Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Staggering Sums of Money...Still More Needed



Clearly, the U.S. government on behalf of 'we the people' needs to spend money to get us out of this economic crisis.  Still, the amount of money is staggering....

Remember: the value of all the goods and services that we produced in this country (the Gross Domestic Product, GDP) in 2008 was about 14.2 Trillion Dollars.

The following table details how the Fed and the government have committed the money on behalf of American taxpayers over the past 20 months, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.



Click on Chart to increase Chart size.

Timothy Geithner and Wall Street

Up until his appointment and confirmation as U.S. Treasury Secretary, Timothy Geithner served as President of the New York Federal Reserve Bank.  What is the role of the New York Fed, you may ask?


"The Federal Reserve was created after a banking crisis nearly a century ago to manage the money supply through interest-rate policy, oversee the safety and soundness of the banking system and act as lender of last resort in times of trouble. The Fed relies on its regional banks, like the New York Fed, to carry out its policies and monitor certain banks in their areas.

The regional reserve banks are unusual entities. They are private and their shares are owned by financial institutions the bank oversees. Their net income is paid to the Treasury.

At the New York Fed, top executives of global financial giants fill many seats on the board. In recent years, board members have included the chief executives of Citigroup and JPMorgan Chase, as well as top officials of Lehman Brothers and industrial companies like General Electric.

In theory, having financiers on the New York Fed’s board should help the president be Washington’s eyes and ears on Wall Street. But critics, including some current and former Federal Reserve officials, say the New York Fed is often more of a Wall Street mouthpiece than a cop."

This begs the question:  Could Geithner's associations with former and current Wall Street CEOs and top-officials cloud his judgement in his official work on behalf of Main Street?  Or even worse?  Perhaps, Obama could have chosen a Treasury Secretary who could have avoided even the appearance of impropriety.  Realistically, this may have been difficult....but usually, if there is a political will, there is a way.

What is the best method for stimulating the economy?